Album Review: The Sherlocks - Everything Must Make Sense!

The Sherlocks return with their fifth album, Everything Must Make Sense!, a confident and vibrant record that pushes the Yorkshire quartet into bigger, more ambitious territory.

The title track kicks things off with punchy guitars and a propulsive rhythm, blending the raw energy of The Strokes with the swagger of early Stereophonics. It sets the tone for an album filled with catchy hooks and anthemic choruses designed for the stadium stage.

Singles like “Bones,” “Death Of Me,” and “Man On The Loose” add fresh layers to the band’s guitar-driven indie rock, introducing shimmering synths and dynamic rhythms. “Bones” stands out with its gritty, almost electronic edge, channeling the intensity of acts like Prodigy and Primal Scream.

Lyrically, frontman Kiaran Crooks tackles mental health, relationship struggles, and the uncertainties of adulthood with sharp honesty. “How Are You Feeling” paints a vivid picture of a toxic relationship falling apart, blending acerbic wit — “She’s been living in your head so long she’ll have to pay some rent” — with emotional depth.

There’s a strong sense of introspection throughout the album, wrapped in infectious melodies. The band explores themes of insecurity and self-discovery, giving the record emotional weight without ever feeling heavy-handed.

Musically, Everything Must Make Sense! bursts with energy. Tracks like “Bedlam Town” and “Tough Times Don’t Last” showcase The Sherlocks’ talent for crafting soaring anthems with precise tension and release. The closing track, “Here Comes The Rain,” offers a powerful finale, with soaring guitars and a sense of catharsis.

Everything Must Make Sense! is The Sherlocks’ most accomplished and ambitious album yet. It combines emotional honesty, strong songwriting, and a confident, live-ready sound that solidifies their position as one of the UK’s most exciting indie bands.